The examples of restorative justice and retributive justice. The biblical call for an eye for an eye is really a call for compensatory justice. Read restorative versus retributive justice essay sample. Although interest in retributive justice is increasing, the fact remains that social psychological research on retribution has tended 1. A system of criminal justice based on the punishment of offende. These are elements in the retributive justice system that are designed for punishment, not for wholeness. Psychological aspects of retributive justice sciencedirect.
In public health terms, restorative justice provides tertiary prevention, introduced after the problem has occurred, with the intention of avoiding reoccurrence. Retributive justice essentially refers to the repair of justice through unilateral imposition of punishment, whereas restorative justice means the repair of justice through reaffirming a shared valueconsensus in a bilateral process. Restorative justice provides alternative values and an alternative vision, not just alternative sentences. International institute for restorative practices defining. Introducing restorative justice into the school setting.
Revisiting the relationship between retributive and. Retributive approach vs restorative approach within a school. Restorative justice is discussed as a paradigm shift away from just deserts. There, he claimed that the current criminal justice systems lens is the retributive. An opportunity for cooperation or an occasion for conflict in the search for justice donald h. The restorative justice theoretical framework views crime as a violation of people and. This article identifies the important features of both restorative and.
The term justice is mostly confused with or used interchangeably, by many people, with the term fairness. Accountability is taking responsibility and repairing harm. The authors the little book of hconferencing program in. The psychology of the restoration of justice after wrongdoing, with an implication of holding omeone auntable for the injustice. Covenant law seeks very different outcomes and requires different processes. Retributive, utilitarian and rehabilitative justice compared the three justice theories or views, which include utilitarianism, rehabilitative or a retributive style of justice, are multifaceted. This is what has inspired me to look deeper into the issue of rj and the south african truth and reconciliation process in this article. Retributive justice is a theory of punishment that when an offender breaks the law, justice requires that she suffers in return. The past, present, and future of restorative justice griffith university. Restorative justice practices provide a useful alternative to our traditional retributive justice model. It is well known in alternative dispute resolution circles and in juvenile courts. As i see it, there are two major obstructions that need to be removed. This process of justice deepens societal wounds and conflicts rather than contributing to healing and peace.
On the other hand, restorative justice is the opposite. Effectiveness of restorative justice principles in juvenile. Retributive justice definition of retributive justice by. The article concludes with an argument in support of the compatibility approach. It is no secret that the criminal justice system, societys means for responding to crime, is far from perfect. Restorative principles 17 three pillars of restorative justice 21 the who and how are important 24 restorative justice aims to put things right 27 a restorative lens 32 five principles of restorative justice 33 defining restorative justice 39 the goals of restorative.
This momentous achievement recognised victims rights and the importance of reparations far beyond. Retributive, restorative, and distributive north american politics, still bearing certain vestiges of christendom, has maintained an ongoing love affair with the notion of justice and, alas, quite often that love affair never moves beyond a notion into concrete practice but i digress. Focus on problemsolving by expressing feelings and needs and how to meet them in the future. Doing restorative justice in a retributive society a speech to the national restorative justice practitioners conference, the widening picture of restorative practises in aotearoa, at the pullman hotel, auckland, on friday 17th may 20. Retributive approach vs restorative approach within a. Retributive justice is sometimes regarded as part of distributive justice, because distributive justice is in turn concerned with what people deserve for their actions.
Pdf the emergence of restorative justice as an alternative model to western, courtbased criminal justice may have important implications for the. In the extract below, just one part of the much longer article, daly addresses what she identifies as the first myth, and argues that advocates of restorative justice have painted a dichotomous, oppositional picture of restorative versus retributive justice. Prevention of future crimes or rehabilitation of the offender are other purposes of punishment. In this lesson, we will explore their differences and how both play a part in our judicial system. Retributive justice and restorative justice tuesday, january 26, 2016. Pdf retributive justice, restorative justice howard. Retributive justice synonyms, retributive justice pronunciation, retributive justice translation, english dictionary definition of. Pdf retributive and restorative justice michael platow. Retributive justice synonyms, retributive justice pronunciation, retributive justice translation, english dictionary definition of retributive justice. Retributive justice is a perspective that focuses on punishment for offenders, while restorative justice focuses on the relationship between the offender and the victim. Prevention of future crimes deterrence or rehabilitation of the offender are other purposes of punishment. Restorative justice is concerned about needs and roles 11 2.
Retributive justice holds that it is intrinsically or noninstrumentally good that wrongdoers suffer at the hands of punishers. Retributive justice is a theory of justice that considers punishment, if proportionate, is a morally acceptable response to crime, by providing satisfaction and psychological benefits to the victim, the offender and society. However there can be a pronounced naivety or romanticism about community within much restorative justice literature. Pdf from retributive justice to restorative justice researchgate. Offender accountability defined as taking punishment. Restorative practices exdefining restorative a graduate school international institute for restorative practices 1. Original article retributive and restorative justice michael wenzel. Retributive, utilitarian and rehabilitative justice compared. This essay addresses the role of punishment in restorative justice and identifies key differences between retributive and restorative justice. Punishment is the main activity of the states response to crime, and restorative justice should be viewed as an alternative punishment rather.
Zerbe therefore, welcome one another, just as christ has welcomed you rom 15. Suffering or costs imposed on the offender in addition to compensation in response to the wrongdoing itself retributive justice in a narrow sense and imposed by a third party authority. To demonstrate the value of restorative justice in practice, it provides some examples of restorative processes in rwanda and in the former. Restorative justice restorative justice is a phrase that is known only in small, concentrated pockets of the united states and other parts of the world. I want to thank the organisers for inviting me to speak at this important conference on the. Nation, and native american peacemaking processes merge spiritual and cultural. European forum of restorative justice and restorative justice consortium, uk and eu it is a concise, engaging, innovative and informative book for. Retributive justice and forgiveness flashcards quizlet. It is proposed that two different notions of justice affect responses to rulebreaking. To some extent, of course, this is a question of nomenclature, but the great bulk of distributive justice research has concerned itself with what one positively deserves, in. Retribution is different from revenge because retributive justice is directed only at wrongs.
Retribution appears alongside restorative principles in law codes from the. An example of restorative justices poor application under a retributive system is that the crown prosecution service in london was barred by national policy from using restorative justice as a possible route of action in half its cases, sherman and strang 2007. Thus, a key difference in the stated aims of retributive and restorative justice turns on the meaning and purpose of punishment. What is the difference between retributive justice and. Traditionally, after a crime, our justice system asks three questions. Retributive justice is a criminal justice theory that has historical roots, with references to it that go far back into ancient times.
Her table comparing the old retributive system of dealing with conflict in schools and a new restorative paradigm for schools is shown below. Justice is the quality of being righteousness, fair. Restorative justice and the south african truth and. Misdemeanour defined as adversely affecting others. The ultimate goal of the theory of retributive justice is not. There is, however, a firm basis for finding a complementarity in the operation of these two processes, which ultimately have the same goal of justice. Until relatively recently, social psychologists have given less attention to retributive justice than to other forms of justice, such as distributive and procedural justice see vidmar, 2001.
In this lesson, well learn the meaning of retribution with a. It is a theory of justice that focuses on the needs of the victims and the offenders. In general, the severity of the punishment is proportionate to the seriousness of the crime. It is not easy to sum the aspects of each without lengthy discussion. Restorative justice in schools old paradigm retributive justice new paradigm restorative justice misdemeanour defined as. Crime is an act against the state, a violation of a law, an abstract idea. Although interest in retributive justice is increasing, the fact remains that social psychological research on. Transitional justice an analysis of restorative and retributive. The emergence of restorative justice as an alternative model to western, courtbased criminal justice may have important implications for the psychology of justice.
Justice has been done when the wrongdoer has been sufficiently punished. This article explores the relationship between retributive justice, restorative justice, and reconciliation. Retributive and restorative justice article pdf available in law and human behavior 325. Retributive justice is a theory of punishment that when an offender breaks the law, justice requires that he or she suffer in return. The articles core premise is that restorative justice has the greatest potential to initiate and further reconciliation and should, therefore, complement the administration of retributive justice. Retributive justice or restorative justice criminology essay. This article investigates the possibilities of retributive and restorative justice approaches to the victimperpetrator relationship by using an extreme example, that is, the 1994 rwandan genocide, and the attempts made by rwandans and the international community to establish the rule of law in its aftermath. An opportunity for cooperation or an occasion for conflict in the search for justice. Crime is an act against individuals and the community. It also requires that the response to a crime is proportional to the offence. Brought together is the theological substance of the entire foregoing argument as christ has. I will begin by exemplifying the idea that whereas the postapartheid truth and reconciliation commission trc did not offer retributive justice, it did promote another. Retributive justice stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
A system of criminal justice which focuses on the rehabilitation of offenders through reconciliation with victims and the community at large. In 1998 the international criminal court the icc was established with a mandate that expressly included victim participation. Restorative justice theory and practice peace palace library. Restorative justice is a noble concept, but if the actual practice does not match the ideal, it could be discredited. Retributive justice is a perspective that focuses on punishment for offenders, while restorative justice focuses on the relationship between the. Retributive justice essentially refers to the repair of justice through unilateral. Restorative justice advocates would likely say that in a restorative justice framework, reparation to the victim or to the community are the primary aims, and punishment is minimised. Restorative justice and retributive justice seattle university. Apr 06, 2018 restorative justice is not retributive justice. Our experience and responsesharing of papers required reading 114pp. The authors the little book of hconferencing program in the u. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades.
In retributive justice, unlike restorative justice, there is no forum or discussion, or the involvement of the victim and community. The two main approaches are the retributive and restorative justice. Justice exam 2 study guide by wiltzsc includes 40 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. In my fortyfive years as a priest, i have found that one of the best things we can do to remove peoples ingrained inability to experience grace and mercy is to first clear away their toxic image of god. Revenge a punitive response by a victim of a crime or transgression. Retributive justice connotes that the offender committed a crime against the state and has thereby violated the law and the moral code of the state. Restorative justice, versus punitive justice, aims to heal, restore and reconcile, while punitive justice seeks punishment and revenge. Restorative justice retributive restorative crime is an act against the state and its laws. Difference between restorative justice and retributive justice. Retributive justice is a theory of justice that considers that punishment, if proportionate, is a morally acceptable response to crime. The practices of restorative justice 32 class seven restorative justice and victim offender conferencing. May 08, 20 this paper will focus on retributive justice and restorative justice. This momentous achievement recognised victims rights.
Pdf retributive and restorative justice researchgate. Retributive justice, response to criminal behaviour that focuses on the punishment of lawbreakers and the compensation of victims. Using the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty and the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr as case studies, it begins by examining whether international war crimes tribunals, as dispensers of retributive justice, can contribute to reconciliation. Restorative versus retributive justice centre for crime and justice. Publications national criminal justice reference service. Crime is an act against another person and the community.
1450 114 506 188 623 907 1569 1430 1388 302 1397 188 246 70 555 722 984 1551 1038 1605 907 231 470 481 105 639 1062 301 1266 1108 515 446 595